SP Premium
50,000-59,999 SparkPoints 53,041

To Weigh or Not to Weigh?

Wednesday, January 04, 2017

There is a lot of controversy over how often a person should step on the scale, and I believe that there is a lot of truth to every opinion.

Option 1~ Don't use the scale. The actual weight is not as important as the fact that you are indeed losing. OK, sure, but how do you measure progress. Well, by your measurements. So, take good measurements when you start and check them once a month or so. This works really well for some people, especially if they have a lot of weight to lose. The heavier you are, the more your weight fluctuates from one day to the next, making daily weigh ins frustrating, So how your clothes fit is a very good way to measure. Also, as you start working out and building muscle, you are going to lose weight caused by fat, and gain weight caused my muscle, so you will probably lose inches even if you don't lose any lbs. Those new muscles will in turn burn more calories which will reduce the amount of fat that your body carries.

Option 2~ monthly or weekly weigh ins. So, your using the scale as a guide, but you know your daily body weight fluctuates, and even though you know that, it is still very discouraging when the dial goes up. So that occasional weigh in gives a more averaged result, and if you are weighing in monthly, and losing 1-2 lbs a week, you will have lost enough to cover a small daily increase, and still see a loss for the month. Weekly you may see a smaller loss or that you maintained, but if you are diligent, you shouldn't see an increase.

Option 3~ daily weigh ins. So, you should know that what you eat and drink today, may not show up on the scale for 2 or 3 days. However, some things like too much sodium have an immediate effect, because sodium causes your cells to hang on to water, causing water weight gain. A daily weigh in keeps me consistent. Its a daily habit, and I don't forget. (my husband doesn't want to weigh in everyday, and therefore, he forgets to ever weigh in). Having stepped on the scale nearly every day for the last 15 years means that I know how my body works, how much fluctuation is normal for me, and when to get nervous about an upward trend. My downward trend is so slow, that even a trend of a fraction of a pound is encouraging to me. I've been in my size 8 jeans for 2 months, and will probably be in them for 3-4 months longer, which means that using measurements or jeans size is a much too slow measurement guide for me.

Option 4~ multiple weigh ins a day. OK, no one recommends this. Its really not a good way to maintain momentum or motivation if the numbers on the scale drive you. Personally, I have been known to fluctuate up as much as 4 lbs at some parts of the day. That being said, there are some benefits to multiple weigh ins. One of those benefits is that it helps you realize how different things effect you. You had a really good BM and think you must have lost 2 lbs? Try jumping on the scale before and after. It's interesting. Did you know that a pint of water equals 1 lb? Drink a pint of water, wait 30-60 minutes, then weigh before and after you pee. Yup, you will lose about a lb. Weighing in before and after your workouts can be helpful as well. Any weight lost during a workout is water weight and it needs to be replace. So if you lose 2 lbs, you need to replace that quart of water. Getting ready to eat a big holiday meal, I dare you, weigh before and after....

OK, I'm sure you can tell from the way this is written what option I follow. I do know that what I do isn't the right thing for everyone, and I'm not trying to sell you on my way of doing things. I did however what to share some insight into how you can use the scale for more than just measuring weight loss or gain.

I took care of my Gramma in my home fore 18 months before she died. She had COPD and was on a low sodium diet which I was very careful with. She was on high levels of oxygen and got out of breath very easily. Occasionally, she would get someone to bring her an unauthorized treat. (how do you tell your 90 yo Gramma she can't have a slice of pizza?) but if she gained more than 1 lbs over night, I knew I had to watch her oxygen levels that day, because that water weight made it very hard for her heart to work.

Regardless of how you have decided to measure your success, you have to use a method that works for you. There really is no right or wrong way. It's really more about how your process the numbers emotionally. If it's working, keep on keeping on, if it isn't working, try something else.
Share This Post With Others
Member Comments About This Blog Post
    Great thoughts!! There's a lot of good info here. I've weighed different ways throughout my journey. I'm with you on the multiple times a day approach. I find it pretty interesting how different things affect the scale. Helps me learn what works!
    1507 days ago
  • no profile photo CD15906132
    Excellent blog!
    1516 days ago
    As a while back I struggled with anorexia weighing myself multiple times a day (I am a 5'9 woman and I was weighing just around 118 lbs) and these eating disorders are a control thing, eventually I realised that I needed to stop doing that. Unfortunately I fell on the other side of the spectrum eating emotionally to cope with my violent family. A few years later I was so heavy, but I had no idea how much I weighted. In the end, I settled for a middle ground and balance, weighing myself once a week I can keep tabs on my progress (or lack thereof) without letting the obsessive part take over. It's a fine balance and I still struggle to keep it. And you are so right, each one of us must find a way to make things work for our unique circumstances. Sorry for the long comment!
    1519 days ago
    I opt for weekly weigh in- and record the official weight.

    I do weigh first thing in the morning as I retain fluid and sodium can really mess me up. I am not obsessed and with the help of information from 100 Days of Weight Loss by Linda Spangler no longer take each weigh in personally. Just another data point for tracking!

    1520 days ago
    You are so right. I am one who obsesses over the scale, but I have tried to weigh in about every other day.
    1520 days ago
  • no profile photo CHAYOR73
    You are so right, it depends on the individual how we feel most comfort in measuring progress. emoticon
    1521 days ago
    I took care of my great grandmother when I was younger. It was a difficult time and also rewarding. I'm very glad I did it. I weigh myself every morning. I can see the changes that different foods do to my body and helps me stay in tune I think.
    1521 days ago
    I go with weekly weigh-ins. Otherwise I either get discouraged or carried away. Weekly is enough to see my progress.
    1521 days ago
  • Add Your Comment to the Blog Post

    Log in to post a comment

    Disclaimer: Weight loss results will vary from person to person. No individual result should be seen as a typical result of following the SparkPeople program.